Marketing needs to change. Right now, one in seven say they would consider leaving their company and the industry based on a lack of diversity and inclusion.
The results of the WFA-led Global DEI Census show we still have work to do. We call on leaders at all levels in marketing organisations and their agency partners to build an industry of true inclusion, one that measures its achievements and is open when it falls short.
From our learnings from the global census, ran in 27 countries around the world, as diverse as Japan, South Africa, Malaysia and Brazil, we strongly recommend the following as the minimum requirements for all organisations, globally.
Action 2: Understand and democratise your companies data
Action 3: Create transparent policies and publish them
Action 4: Create psychological safety and support
Actions around protected characteristics
Age
Caregiving
Gender
Race and ethnicity
Disability and neurodivergence
Sexual orientation and gender identity
Mental health
Learn how to get involved
Create a diverse leadership team
Leadership must reflect the diversity of our global consumers and the richness of our intersectional identities.
Where groups are not represented, leadership must have strategies for short-term progress and beyond.
Investment in sponsorship schemes, reverse mentorship programmes and smart succession planning can create career growth for those in the organisation and attract new diverse leaders as well.
Understand and democratise your company's data
Leaders need to understand the data of inclusion: who is being promoted at every level and what barriers are holding particular groups back.
Measuring what you treasure is essential, however beware of bias in existing systems.
Guidance on effective change can also come via continuous feedback, listening sessions and/or employee networks.
Data should be accessible to everyone internally as part of a commitment to tackling the issues.
Create transparent policies and publish them
Organisations must strengthen anti-discrimination policies and be transparent in policies, expectations of leaders and employees, and how to escalate situations when needed.
These approaches must consider the nuances of multiple identities and ensure policies are accessible and widely shared.
Ensuring they are being implemented is equally critical.
Create psychological safety and support
Genuinely safe spaces allow employees to speak up candidly.
Companies must invest in qualified facilitation for these spaces and have clear rules of engagement.
Middle management is key, so provide training and continual support on managing diversity and running inclusive teams.
How others are tackling the challenges:
Making DEI a top area of focus
To stand any chance of fighting inequality through inclusive business and branding, we need leaders who will drive ED&I…
Why? More than a quarter of respondents agreed that their company does not treat all employees equally when it comes to age.
Key actions: Providing continued coaching, mentoring, and career development for experienced and younger employees alike shows the organization is committed to supporting and retaining all forms of talent, irrespective of age.
Idea to steal: Consider running reverse mentoring programmes as a way of connecting senior leaders with the next generation of talent. This empowers more junior employees to develop confidence and leadership skills, while at the same time allowing senior management to develop new skills sets.
How others are tackling the challenges:
Beyond reverse mentoring: avoiding age-bias in recruitment
Why?More than a quarter of respondents agreed that their company does not treat all employees equally when it comes to their caregiving responsibilities, rising to 40% among female respondents.
Key actions: Ensuring that decision-maker roles include leaders with caregiving responsibilities – for the young, but also for the elderly and the sick – can both serve as a positive example to others and encourage the adoption of flexible policies. Adding emergency caregiver support to employer benefits plans can actively support those with caregiving responsibilities.
Idea to steal: Companies should think of adopting policies that benefit parents and employees providing care to aging or sick relatives alike. Research showed that the focus of family-friendly policies favours parents over other caregivers. Failing to narrow that gap could potentially push some employees out of the workforce.
Why? Women reported a low sense of belonging and more negative behaviours at work: a third said they felt undervalued and less than half agreed that management do not discriminate when it comes to hiring or career advancements.
Key action:Businesses need to understand and improve women’s lived experiences. Support plans need to be tailored to the cultural differences and employment conditions in each market, so that women feel valued and provided with sufficient support to progress their careers.
Idea to steal: The Diageo-led #CreativeComeback is a global creative ‘returners’ scheme to support women, non-binary and gender non-conforming creatives as they return to work after a career break of at least 12 months. Read more.
Why?In 15 of the 21 markets where race and ethnicity were measured, minorities were less likely to agree that organisations were actively taking steps to be more diverse and inclusive as were their majority counterparts.
Key action: Creating programs and spaces specifically designed to support and empower ethnic minorities helps show commitment and progress to populations that usually report poorer lived experiences.
Idea to steal: L’AACC launched tailor-made training program offering 17 young people, aged 18 to 25, from priority neighbourhoods in Paris, to develop the skills necessary to train for creative jobs in advertising agencies. Read more
How others are tackling the challenges:
Scared to speak up about DEI or sustainability in the current environment? Don’t be: fortune favours the bold
Why? People with disabilities are under-represented in the industry and tend to report a lower sense of belonging.
Key actions:Businesses should prioritise actions which help normalise and improve understanding of all forms of disability. Accessibility needs must be discovered and accommodated as part of the employee onboarding experience.
Why? 35% of LGBTQ+ respondents reported feeling consistently anxious in their jobs compared to 27% of non-LGBTQIA+ respondents.
Key actions: Companies must have policies in place to protect but also support LBGTQ+ employees. Benefits including pay, bonuses, parental leave, health insurance should be explicitly available to same-sex couples. Non-binary identifying employees should have their chosen identity recognised.
Idea to steal: Reach out to LGBTQ+ industry advocacy organisations, such as GLAAD (USA) and Outvertising (UK), which employer resources and training, including Ally and Role Model training.
How others are tackling the challenges:
Scared to speak up about DEI or sustainability in the current environment? Don’t be: fortune favours the bold
Why? 7% of respondents globally reported a long-term health condition and of these, 71% said they related to mental health. Moreover, a third of all respondents reported feeling stressed and anxious at work.
Key action: Providing and continually promoting mental health benefits so that they are accessible and top of mind is important. People managers should be trained in how to respond to mental health issues and have supportive discussions around mental health with employees.
Idea to steal: In 2021, Publicis Groupe rebranded Personal Leave as Wellbeing Leave, in recognition that when people get sick, it can be for physical or mental health reasons. Read more here.
How others are tackling the challenges:
Creating frameworks to encourage taking care of mental health
The Global DEI Charter for Change was developed with the input of members of the WFA Diversity & Inclusion Taskforce and other industry organisations, such as VoxComm, EACA and Creative Equals. To all those who shared their experience, learnings and insights with us, we are incredibly grateful.
For more information or questions, please contact us
That is why we want to let you know that we use cookies and similar technologies to measure traffic on and engagement with our website. That way we can remember your choices and preferences. Other than strictly necessary ones, cookies will only be set if you agree. Please indicate below which cookies and similar technologies you agree we may use: